(Episode starts at the house, then cuts inside with Muriel and Eustace watching a movie, following another cut to the kitchen with Courage getting milk with a slice of a pie and putting the milk back in the fridge, where he drinks his milk. A noise is heard outside; Courage looks out the window to investigate and find out the noise, where he sees a monster eating things with its shadow being seen. Back in the kitchen, Courage grabs out a fan to calm himself down, then runs to the living room. In the living room, Eustace and Muriel are sleeping, when Courage enters causing the two to wake up. Courage explains with what he's saying coming out as gibberish and pretending to be a monster.)
Eustace: (laughs) You stupid dog.
Muriel: What is it, Courage?
(Courage points at the kitchen while jumping.)
Courage: Help, help, help.
(Cuts to the outside of the kitchen door. Muriel opens the door and Courage and Muriel looks at the garbage scattered across the ground)
Muriel: Oh, it's just the raccoons. They must hungry.
(Courage looks at the garbage.)
Courage: That was no raccoon.
(Back in the kitchen, Muriel grabs a pie from the oven and puts it on the window to let the pie cool off.)
Muriel: This is our lovely dessert for tomorrow.
Courage: I hope we make it until tomorrow.
(Cuts to the bedroom with Muriel and Eustace sleeping. Courage is looking out the window, then he grabs a pair of binoculars, seeing something. He goes down the stairs with the binoculars on and falls down the stairs. He runs to the kitchen. Courage sees the pie moving weirdly. He grabs the pie to prevent it from going away.)
Courage: Raccoon or not, you're not getting this pie.
(The monster pulled hard, Courage is almost pulled out and he pulls himself in the window and pulls back. The monster lets go of the pie throwing Courage into the wall splating himself and the wall with the pie. Muriel walks in.)
Muriel: (Clears throat and Courage gasps)
Courage: But, but, but?
Muriel: It's all right Courage, I'll make another pie in the morning.
Courage: But, but, but?
Muriel: Next time, use a plate.
(Muriel leaves the kitchen and Courage looks at window, where he sees a chicken, barn and the windmill still creaking.)
Courage: There was something on the other end of this pie, or my name is Aloysius, and that's not. (Courage takes a pie blueberry and eats it for pie)
News reporter: Bigfoot is on the loose Reward!!!
Courage: I wonder if that was Bigfoot last night.
(He looks around outside and finds a humongous foot print.)
To be continued